The Surprising Breathing Mistake That Everybody Makes

“Take a deep breath.”

Have you ever been told to do that? I certainly have! “Breathe deep…” that’s what instructors have told me during hard workouts as I sweat and sputter for air. I’ve had kind friends tell me to “just breathe deep!” when I’m going through a stressful moment.

This sounds like a good idea, because deep inhales calm you down, right? Well…actually no.

In fact, taking a deep breath is the last thing you want to do if you’re trying to calm down!

One of the best things you can do to calm and destress is to hold your breath.

Sounds crazy, I know! Because everyone always tells you to breathe, and we’ve all heard that breath-holding is really bad for us. That is true but also NOT True! Okay…let me break this down a bit.

Holding our breath is really unhealthy if we are unaware that we are doing it.

Disorders such as sleep apnea are harmful, unconscious forms of breath-holding. We want to avoid this for sure!

A new form of unhealthy, unconscious breath-holding is becoming more common and leading to all kinds of problems. This type of breath-holding occurs when we are constantly shifting between tasks and never focusing on one thing for a sustained period of time. Without realizing it, we forget to breathe.

Our current lifestyle promotes this scattered attention. With computers, phones, and watches pinging us all day long we can’t stay focused even if we try!

This form of unconscious breath-holding, now dubbed “email apnea” is very problematic- leading to poor digestion, increased stress hormone production, increased blood pressure, a dampened immune system, decreased ability to focus, and interrupted sleep. After months or years of this, your neck and shoulders get tight on top of everything else.

So why am I telling you that you should hold your breath? Because when you consciously hold your breath, all sorts of wonderful things happen.

Breath Holding for Clarity of Mind

Yes, it’s true, when you hold your breath you start to feel anxious, irritable, and hyper-focused on getting air in. But this momentary air hunger results in a state of peace and calm once you are finished with the technique. Over time this relaxed state becomes more and more prominent because your tolerance to carbon dioxide is increasing and your breathing patterns are becoming normalized at rest.

Yogis have been practicing breath-holding techniques for thousands of years.

At that time they already knew that there were health benefits, and now we know the science behind it.

By exposing the chemical sensors in your arteries to greater and greater levels of carbon dioxide by holding your breath, you restore normal breathing patterns that have been disrupted due to minor (or major) stressors in your life.

Yogis would often use breath-holding techniques as a way to prepare for sitting in meditation because as breathing normalizes, thinking becomes clearer.

But don’t worry! You don’t have to meditate to get all the benefits. Just doing the breathing techniques are enough.

Breath-Holding and Anxiety

Breath-holding techniques have been shown to help with anxiety and depression disorders (of which 50% of Americans will suffer one of).

The problem is, patients with anxiety have a much greater fear of holding their breath. To avoid the sensation of air hunger- which is inherently anxiety producing- they over-breathe.

Over time, their chemical sensors tolerate less and less carbon dioxide, and it becomes harder and harder to hold your breath. This cycle creates more anxiety, more over-breathing, and so on.

Slow breathing is taught to people who suffer from panic attacks because it increases carbon dioxide levels without the fear-inducing capacity of breath holding. So, if you know that you tend toward anxiety or panic attacks, try slow breathing first.

If you are feeling stressed, anxious, or panicky, your body is already increasing your oxygen levels and reducing your carbon dioxide levels. If this continues, a panic attack can occur. By increasing and maintaining higher levels of carbon dioxide, the anxiety can be prevented before it even starts.

So, instead of taking a deep breath, try holding your breath!

This will increase your carbon dioxide levels and trigger your chemoreceptors to increase your tolerance to carbon dioxide. At first, while holding your breath, you may feel MORE anxious, uncomfortable, irritable. Your body will scream at you to breathe. But AFTER you hold your breath, the opposite happens. You become relaxed, calm, clear-headed.

Precautions

A word of warning: do NOT try this technique if you are pregnant or if you have cardiac issues or heart problems. This technique is also not appropriate for children under age 12.

How to Do It:

To practice breath-holding, make sure to breathe slowly and smoothly in through the nose and out through the nose. If your breath becomes ragged or uneven, or you are feeling very anxious or panicked, reduce the time of holding until you can perform the exercise comfortably while still reaching the sense of slight urge to inhale.

Here’s what to do:

  1. Slowly inhale to the count of four.
  2. Exhale fully but slowly also to the count of four.
  3. Hold your breath when you are done exhaling for a count of four.
  4. Repeat this breath cycle for 1-2 minutes.
  5. You can increase or decrease the count depending on if it feels easy or too challenging, for example holding each stage for only 2 seconds if it feels very hard, or 5 seconds if it feels easy.
  6. *Aim to hold the breath for the same duration as the inhalation and the exhalation. This is a goal to work toward if holding your breath is hard initially.

A few things to keep in mind:

  1. Don’t over-effort to hold your breath, work within your range of sensing some air hunger but not over doing it.
  2. Practice this technique sitting or laying down. Do not do this technique while standing.
  3. Keep your mouth closed and breathe through your nose as much as possible.
  4. Practice this breathing technique on an empty stomach if possible.

Potential Health Benefits:

  1. Improved diaphragm function.
  2. Increased lung capacity.
  3. Cleared out residual, dead air from the lungs. 
  4. Restored function of the respiratory center in the brain (due to the increase in carbon dioxide during breath-holding).
  5. Increased oxygen off-loading to tissues, resulting in improved breathing efficiency and endurance.
  6. Reduced stress and anxiety.
  7. Clearer thinking.
  8. Improved circulation.
  9. May help with relieve digestive problems, allergies, asthma, and auto-immune disorders.

The Most Misunderstood Molecule, and How to Harness Its Power

Deeper, quieter, regular, slower.

Those are the general guidelines for focusing our attention on the breath. This awareness makes us feel calmer, more relaxed, and releases tension from our bodies.

But How? Why does changing our breath change our mood, and many other factors?

Research has shown that slower, deeper breathing reduces heart rate and risk for cardiovascular disease, as well as improves athletic performance. (yes, all you athletes out there, breathe slower to go faster).

The reason all these magnificent changes occur within us when we deepen our breath, especially our exhales, is because of a very special molecule that usually gets a bad rap.

I’m talking about good old carbon dioxide, CO2.

I know what you’re thinking…is she talking about the very same carbon dioxide that we are trying to reduce in our atmosphere to slow global warming? The same carbon dioxide that is considered a waste product of our bodies- something useless to to be rid of as soon as possible?

Well, yes, I am.

But what if I told you that this special little molecule was not only a useful component in improving your health, but an essential one for you to be able to thrive?

You see, for our bodies to get oxygen from our lungs to our tissues, we need carbon dioxide. To get a proper inhale, our receptors in our neck need to sense a certain amount of carbon dioxide in our bodies.

Not to mention, carbon dioxide is stored as bicarbonate in your blood stream, which is essential for maintaining the pH balance of your whole body.

Did I mention that carbon dioxide is critical in weight loss? Most of your body mass lost is due to breathing out carbon dioxide. In fact, more than 80% of weight loss is due to breathing out CO2, and only 15% or so is lost via sweat and urine.

So, if you’ve been dieting, exercising, doing all the right things and still not losing weight… you may want to look at how you’re breathing.

Let’s explore some of these in a little detail…

Firstly, how the heck does carbon dioxide help your body get more oxygen?

Think of carbon dioxide as the Fedex guy, and oxygen as your packages. When outside air hits your lungs, it makes it’s way down to alveoli, the tiny air sacs that interface with the blood stream. The oxygen molecules (packages) get loaded from the alveoli onto the red blood cell, which in this analogy is the Fedex truck.

The truck travels all over the body, delivering oxygen to all the cells as they all need oxygen to survive and flourish. When exercising, certain muscles need even more oxygen more quickly.

This is where our good buddy carbon dioxide comes in.

Oxygen cannot get off the truck unless there is a carbon dioxide molecule there to unload it.

When the oxygen gets to its destination, the carbon dioxide triggers the packages (oxygen) to be unloaded off the Fedex Truck (red blood cell), and be delivered to the cells (your mailbox).

The more carbon dioxide present, the more efficiently the oxygen can be offloaded to cells.

So, when you’re exercising and you really need to get oxygen to those tissues, perhaps try breathing slower instead of faster.

Why does the amount of CO2 in your body determine how you inhale?

I’m constantly telling my patients, don’t worry about the inhale! If you get a good exhale, the inhale will just come.

This is for two reasons, the first of which is purely mechanical.

When you exhale completely, the lungs become essentially “empty” of air, which creates a vacuum. New air has to flow in. It must follow the laws of nature! It must flow from the higher pressure (outside your body) to the lower pressure (inside your lungs). You don’t have to use your accessory muscles (aka your neck) to pull air in, it just goes in! Easy.

The second reason is neurological.

Deep in the reptilian brain, the most primal part of our brain that was present when the first creature crawled out of the primordial goo and decided to walk on land, there is a simple neural network that says, “breathe.”

This network senses levels of oxygen and CO2 in your body to decide when to inhale or exhale. Basically, when your body senses a certain level of oxygen in your body, that circuit makes you exhale. Similarly, when a certain level of CO2 is sensed, the circuit makes your body inhale.

Unfortunately, for many of us, this circuit gets messed up.

We breathe shallowly because we are less active, or stressed, or both, and we do this so much that we end up overriding the part of the circuit that senses CO2 and tells you to inhale.

We get stuck in this cycle of inhaling without ever getting to the bottom of our breath; we lose that primal trigger to inhale, so our inhales get all wonky, a.k.a. you end up pulling your ribcage up with your neck.

In addition to all these important factors, carbon dioxide is the main reason that you feel relaxed with deeper breathing.

Carbon dioxide makes you chill out.

Think about it. What do they tell you to do when you’re having a panic attack? Breathe into a paper bag. You’re breathing back in the CO2 you exhaled. Get that CO2 flowin’ baby!

Carbon dioxide relaxes you by causing your blood vessels to relax, which allows blood to deliver oxygen to all your tissues more easily.

Also, as mentioned above, CO2 lets your body unload oxygen from red blood cells to tissues.

These two factors together mean that your brain gets more oxygen and blood flow. This tells your body that you are safe, and you feel calmer and, well, more chill!

So how to insure that you get more CO2, but not too much?

The answer is simple, and I think you know what I’m going to say.

Breathe deeper, quieter, regular, slower.

5-6 seconds for each inhale and exhale, resulting in about 5-6 breaths per minute, is the ideal for balancing the CO2 and O2 in your body.

Below is a short video on how to do just that and harness the power of this special molecule.

Are you ready to breathe better to move better, to improve the health and resiliency of your lungs without any medication or procedures? Click the button below to find out if will benefit from working with Dr. Derya.

References

Aakash K. Patel; Andrew Benner; Jeffrey S. Cooper. Physiology, Bohr Effect.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK526028/

Anders Olsson Blog https://www.consciousbreathing.com/anders-olsson/carbon-dioxide-training-extremely-harmonious/

Nestor, James. Breath: The New Science of a Lost Art. May 14, 2020 http://www.pathwaymedicine.org/control-of-respiration

Call Dr. Derya